Skip to content
Sam AkbariFractional CXO
All insights

Fractional leadership

Fractional executive vs consultant: which do you need?

A consultant advises on a defined problem; a fractional executive owns a function and its results. How to tell which you need, and what each costs in Australia.

Sam Akbari · 8 min read

Short answer: hire a consultant when you need an independent answer to a defined question: a review, a strategy, a recommendation, delivered and handed over. Hire a fractional executive when you need someone to own a function and its results, inside your leadership team, for six to twelve months. The test is ownership: if you’ll still need someone to make the plan happen after the report lands, you need an executive, not a consultant.

I’ve been on both sides of this. I founded and ran a consulting and systems integration business, and I’ve held the executive seat that answers for what consultants deliver. Both models are useful. Most of the disappointment I’ve seen comes from buying one when you needed the other.

What’s the difference between a fractional executive and a consultant?

A consultant is engaged to produce something: a diagnosis, a strategy, a recommendation, a business case. A fractional executive is engaged to run something: a function, a team, a number.

That difference shows up everywhere else in the engagement.

Consultant Fractional executive
What you’re buying An independent output: research, advice, a recommendation A role in your leadership team, part-time
Who owns the outcome You do. The consultant owns the quality of the advice The executive, for the results agreed with the CEO
Who directs the work The consultant, within the agreed scope Shared: the executive runs the function and reports to the CEO
Manages your people Rarely Yes, usually the team in their function
Typical length Weeks to a few months Six to twelve months, often longer
How it’s paid A fixed fee, milestones or day rates A monthly retainer for a set number of days
How it ends The deliverable is handed over The team or a permanent hire takes over the function

None of this makes one better than the other. A good consultant gives you something a fractional executive often can’t: distance. They aren’t part of the leadership team, so they can tell you things the leadership team doesn’t want to hear.

How does the Australian Government tell a consultant from a contractor?

There’s a useful, neutral test hiding in Commonwealth procurement guidance. The Department of Finance has to decide which contracts count as consultancies for annual reporting, and its contract characteristics guidance says the difference “generally depends on the nature of the services and the level of direction and control”.

In its table, a consultancy:

  • involves specialist knowledge “that may not be maintained in-house”
  • produces an intellectual output, such as research, evaluation, advice or recommendations, to help the entity decide
  • is a one-off task or a set of irregular tasks
  • is performed largely at the consultant’s discretion, and the output reflects their independent views
  • is usually paid on milestones or completion

Work that is “an integral part of the entity’s business”, done day to day and paid for time worked, sits on the other side of the line.

That’s a procurement test, not an employment law one, but it maps neatly onto the private-sector choice. If what you need is an independent view to inform a decision, you’re describing a consultant. If what you need is someone to run a part of the business that’s integral to it, every week, you’re describing an executive, and a fractional one if the work fills one to three days a week rather than five.

What does each cost in Australia?

There’s no neutral Australian survey of management consulting fees. The figures below are the best published ones I could find, so treat them as ranges, not prices.

Option What it typically costs Source
Boutique consultant, narrow defined problem A$5,000–A$20,000 a project Fractionus (a fractional marketplace)
Mid-tier consulting firm A$30,000–A$100,000 a project Fractionus
Large firm strategy engagement A$300,000 or more Fractionus
Contract program director (delivery, full-time) A$1,400–A$1,800 a day, median A$1,600 Morgan McKinley 2026 salary guide
Fractional executive, one to two days a week A$7,000–A$18,000 a month Fractionus, and my cost guide
My diagnostic sprint, about two weeks From A$15,000 + GST How I work
My fractional seat, about one day a week From A$12,000 + GST a month How I work

The invoice is the wrong comparison, though. Six months of a fractional seat at A$12,000 a month is A$72,000. A mid-tier strategy project might cost the same and arrive in eight weeks. The difference is what you hold at the end: a plan your team still has to deliver, or a function that has been running to the plan for six months.

If you buy the report, budget for whoever will implement it. If that’s your existing team, budget their time too, because the work lands on top of their day jobs. The most expensive consulting report is the one nobody has the capacity to act on.

When should you hire a consultant?

A consultant is the right call when:

  • You need an independent view. A board wants an assessment that isn’t shaped by management, or an investor wants due diligence.
  • The question is defined and one-off. A pricing review, a market entry assessment, a vendor selection, a business case.
  • You need specialist knowledge you won’t need again. A regulatory change, a particular system, a transaction.
  • Your team can implement, but can’t see the problem. They’re capable and close to it. They need a diagnosis, not a manager.

If you go this way, decide before you start whether you want the consultant to diagnose the problem only, or to recommend the fix as well. I call that choice Prescriptive or Descriptive, and settling it up front avoids most of the disappointment.

When do you need a fractional executive?

A fractional executive is the right call when:

  • A function needs leading, not reviewing. Revenue, operations or AI is underperforming because nobody senior owns it, and the CEO is filling the gap.
  • The work runs for months. The fix involves people, process and systems changing over two or three quarters, not a single decision.
  • You’ve already had the report. You know what to do. Nobody has the time or authority to do it.
  • There’s one to three days a week of senior work. Enough to need an executive, not enough for a full-time one.

The global launch work I took on at a consumer brand is a good example of executive-shaped work. Every launch meant coordinating eight internal teams, four regions and fourteen agencies, and the know-how lived in people’s heads. Nobody needed a report telling them launches were hard. They needed someone to own the process until it was redesigned, and the result was one intake form that triggers 450 tasks.

If the function is revenue, that’s a fractional CRO or CMO. If it’s how the business runs, a fractional COO. If it’s AI, a fractional Chief AI Officer.

Can you use both?

Yes, and the sequence matters more than the choice.

Diagnose, then own. A short, fixed-fee diagnostic finds the real problem, then a fractional executive owns the fix. It works because the person who owns the fix starts from an agreed diagnosis, and it’s how I structure my own diagnostic sprint: about two weeks, board-ready findings and a 90-day plan. Sometimes the plan says you need a fractional seat. Sometimes it says your team can do it, which is a useful answer too.

Consultant to owner. At an ASX-listed technology company I was first engaged as a consultant to build a global go-to-market strategy. The company then created the Chief Revenue & Marketing Officer role and I took it on, owning a global P&L of around A$15M. Writing the strategy and then owning its delivery meant the plan had to survive contact with reality.

Owner plus specialist. A fractional executive running a function will sometimes bring in a consultant for a narrow specialist question. That works well, because someone inside the business is ready to act on the answer.

Two cautions. First, a consultant who diagnoses the problem and hopes to sell the fix has a reason to find a problem their fix solves. Second, an executive who is grading their own plan isn’t independent. If either worries you, separate the roles.

Five questions to decide

  1. Who will own the outcome a year from now? If the honest answer is “the consultant”, you need an executive.
  2. Do we know what the problem is? If not, diagnose first.
  3. Is this a decision or a function? A decision needs advice. A function needs leadership.
  4. Who will implement the recommendations, and do they have the time?
  5. Do we need independence, or commitment? A board review needs the first. A turnaround needs the second.

If you’re also weighing interim cover, my fractional vs interim executive guide compares all three models side by side.

The bottom line

Buy a consultant for an answer. Buy a fractional executive for an outcome. Many mid-market businesses already have the answer, sometimes in more than one report. What they’re missing is someone senior to own it.

If you’re not sure which you need, book a 30-minute call and we’ll work it out. If what you need is a consultant, I’ll tell you, and if it’s a fractional COO or CRO, we’ll talk about how the first 90 days would look. Once you’ve decided, my one-page fractional executive brief helps you write it down.

Common questions

What is the difference between a fractional executive and a consultant?

A consultant is engaged to produce an independent output, such as a review, a strategy or a recommendation, and the engagement ends when it's delivered. A fractional executive holds a role in your leadership team part-time, manages people and owns the results of a function over months. The simplest test is who answers for the outcome a year from now.

Is a fractional executive cheaper than a consultant?

Not always per engagement, but often per result. A boutique consultant can deliver a narrow, well-defined piece of work for less than three months of a fractional seat. For a function that needs leading over six to twelve months, a fractional executive is usually better value, because you aren't paying again to implement the report.

Can a consultant become a fractional executive?

Yes, and it often works well, because they already know the business. Treat it as a new engagement with a new brief, though. The scope, the authority and the measures of success change when someone moves from advising to owning.

Do I need a consultant before I hire a fractional executive?

Only if you don't know what the problem is. If the issue and the function are clear, start the fractional seat and let the first 30 days be the diagnosis. If they aren't, a short fixed-fee diagnostic first will stop you hiring the wrong role.

Is a fractional executive an employee?

Usually not. Most fractional executives work under a services agreement and invoice through their own company. Whether someone is an employee or a contractor under Australian law depends on the whole relationship, so get advice if the arrangement looks like a job in everything but name.

Keep reading

Let's talk about what's next for your business.

A 30-minute conversation, no pitch deck. If I'm not the right fit, I'll tell you, and point you to someone who is.